Dish × condiment pairing
Which cinnamon for pumpkin pie?
Season : autumn, winter · Occasion : thanksgiving, holiday
Saigon cinnamon. Pumpkin is mellow and a custard pie cooks long, so you want the hot, sweet bark that drives a classic Thanksgiving pie, not a soft Ceylon that the squash swallows. Whisk it into the custard with ginger, clove and nutmeg. About $11 for a single-origin jar.
In detail
The best cinnamon for pumpkin pie is Saigon cinnamon, whisked into the custard with ginger, clove and nutmeg. Pumpkin is mild and sweet, and a custard pie bakes long and slow, so the cinnamon has to carry through both the squash and the egg. Saigon, the bark of a Vietnamese cassia, carries one of the highest essential-oil concentrations of any cinnamon, 4 to 6%, rich in the cinnamaldehyde that reads as the hot, candy-sweet spice we recognize as 'pumpkin pie spice.' It stays in the foreground through a long bake where delicate Ceylon fades. Use about one to one and a half teaspoons for a nine-inch pie, scaling back from a generic cinnamon since Saigon hits harder per spoon. Building your own blend around fresh Saigon beats a pre-mixed pumpkin pie spice that's been sitting on the shelf losing its punch. Burlap & Barrel's single-origin Royal Cinnamon runs about $11 a jar.
Our recommendation
Spice · Whole spice
Saigon Cinnamon
Highland forests around Huế and Quảng Nam, central Vietnam, Vietnam
hot cinnamon candy · sweet bark · clove-like warmth
Pumpkin is mild and sweet, and a custard pie bakes slow, so the cinnamon has to push through both. Saigon, a cassia with 4 to 6% essential oil, brings the hot, candy-sweet bark that reads as 'pumpkin pie spice' in the first place, and it holds through a long bake where Ceylon fades. Whisk it into the custard with ginger and clove. About $11 a jar, the spice doing the heavy lifting.
Intensity 7/10
Where to buy it
Prices checked on
| Merchant | Price | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Burlap & Barrel | — | Burlap & Barrel |
| Amazon US | — | Amazon US |
| The Spice House | — | The Spice House |
Prices may vary depending on current promotions on the merchant site.
Affiliate links — La Pincée may earn a commission on some sales, at no extra cost to you. Read more.
The catch
Don't lean on a jar of pre-mixed pumpkin pie spice that's been in the cupboard since last Thanksgiving. Cinnamon loses its top notes within a year, so a tired blend tastes of dust, and pumpkin is too mellow to cover for it. Build the spice yourself around fresh Saigon. Skip that and your pie tastes flat no matter how good the custard is.
Chef's note
Bloom the spice in the wet, not the dry. Whisk your Saigon, ginger, clove and nutmeg into the warm condensed milk or cream before you add the egg and pumpkin, and let it sit five minutes. The fat draws out the cinnamon's oil-soluble aromatics so the spice reads through the whole custard rather than clumping. One to one and a half teaspoons of Saigon for a nine-inch pie.
Tasting note
hot cinnamon candy · sweet bark · clove · baked custard warmth · about $11 for the single-origin jar, and fresh cinnamon is the cheapest fix for a flat pie. Worth it; supermarket Saigon also works.
These three sections appear on every one of our pairing pages — our methodology.
Alternatives to explore
-
Spice · Whole spice
Star Anise
Lang Son province, on the Chinese border, Vietnam
A whisper of ground star anise deepens a pumpkin pie's warm-spice background, but use a tiny amount; its licorice edge takes over fast. Cinnamon stays the lead.
Complementary ingredients
- Star Anise — A tiny pinch, ground, for warm-spice depth behind the cinnamon
Frequently asked questions
- How much cinnamon goes in a pumpkin pie?
- About one to one and a half teaspoons of Saigon for a standard nine-inch pie, whisked into the custard with the ginger, clove and nutmeg. Scale back from a generic cinnamon, since Saigon is noticeably hotter and sweeter per spoon.
- Can I use Saigon cinnamon instead of pumpkin pie spice?
- Yes, and it's better. Most pumpkin pie spice blends are cinnamon-led anyway, so building your own around Saigon plus ginger, clove and nutmeg gives a fresher, punchier result than a pre-mixed jar that's been sitting on the shelf.
- Why does my pumpkin pie taste flat and dusty?
- Usually stale ground cinnamon. Cinnamon loses its top notes within a year, so a tired jar tastes of cardboard. Fresh Saigon, with its high oil content, gives the hot, sweet lift a mild or old cinnamon can't.
This pairing was validated according to our methodology. Purchase links are marked sponsored and may earn a commission — details on our Affiliations page.